Judge acquits brothers accused of $25M Ethereum exploit, finding fraud unproven
A federal judge on Monday ordered the acquittal of two Massachusetts Institute of Technology-educated brothers on US charges that they stole about $25 million in cryptocurrency by exploiting Ethereum in roughly 12 seconds, Reuters reported. The judge ruled that prosecutors failed to prove the brothers committed fraud, meaning the government’s theory that the exploit itself amounted to fraud did not survive trial. The decision comes from a single federal district court, and the Reuters account available here is truncated after its opening line, so whether it sets any broader precedent for treating protocol exploits as fraud is not yet established.
Verified and unconfirmed
- Verified: Reuters reported that a US federal judge on Monday ordered the acquittal of two MIT-educated brothers charged over a $25 million cryptocurrency theft carried out by exploiting Ethereum, with the court finding prosecutors failed to prove fraud.
- Not yet confirmed: the judge’s full reasoning, the specific legal theory the court rejected, whether the government will appeal, and the exact mechanics of the alleged 12-second exploit all rest on a truncated Reuters summary; no court filing or second independent account was reviewed.
Background
The case dates to April 2023, when prosecutors alleged the two Peraire-Bueno brothers took about $25 million in Ethereum in roughly 12 seconds, a scheme they described as first-of-its-kind. A first trial was presided over by U.S. District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke, and reporting before the verdict noted the unusual effort to seat an educated jury, half of whose members held master’s degrees. The acquittal closes that prosecution rather than an earlier stage of it: the same allegations that were aired at trial have now been rejected by the court.
Why it matters
The acquittal sets a higher proof bar for federal crypto-fraud prosecutions: the judge found that prosecutors did not prove fraud from the alleged exploitation of Ethereum’s own mechanics, so a fast, code-level maneuver that moves $25 million is not by itself a crime in this court. For developers and traders using similar tactics — for example MEV (maximal extractable value) strategies that reorder pending transactions for profit — the lesson is that criminal exposure now hinges on how the conduct is presented and executed, not just on the size of the loss. The ruling is a single district-court acquittal, not binding precedent, and DOJ continues to bring criminal crypto cases that can run parallel to civil enforcement, so the boundary remains unsettled.
What to watch
Whether federal prosecutors appeal the acquittal or bring a revised charge, and whether the court publishes a fuller written opinion explaining why the Ethereum exploit did not amount to fraud.
Further reading
-
[MIT - educated brothers face trial over $ 25 M Ethereum … MEXC News](https://www.mexc.co/news/131437) - MIT - educated brothers arrested for stealing $ 25 million in crypto in…
- The feds say two brothers stole $ 25 million in crypto in 12 seconds .
- Crypto Enforcement Tracker (2024-2026): SEC and CFTC
- SEC Enforcement Actions Against Crypto Exchanges
Comments
Comments use a GitHub account and are moderated. Comment rules